22 days left — Registration closes 2026-10-31.

Legal Reasoning · 5 questions · about 1 min to read

The Public Trust Doctrine

Read the passage, answer the questions, then open each answer to check it. The explanation says why the right option is right.

The passage

Read, then answer

The doctrine of public trust holds that certain natural resources — historically air, water, and seashore — are held by the state in trust for the public and cannot be alienated or appropriated for private use in a manner that deprives the public of access to and enjoyment of these resources. The doctrine has ancient roots in Roman law (the Justinian Code) and was incorporated into English common law.

In Indian constitutional jurisprudence, the doctrine was applied by the Supreme Court in M.C. Mehta v. Kamal Nath (1997), where the court held that the state cannot transfer public trust resources to private parties in a manner inconsistent with the trust. The case involved a motel that had encroached on the bed and banks of the Beas river. The court ordered the restoration of the riverbed to its natural course and the demolition of constructions in the riverbed.

The doctrine has since been extended by Indian courts to cover forests, wildlife habitats, and other ecologically sensitive areas. It provides a constitutional basis for environmental litigation, allowing citizens to approach courts when the state fails to protect resources held in public trust.

  1. Q1. The doctrine of public trust holds that natural resources like water and air:

    1. Are the absolute property of the state, which may deal with them as it pleases
    2. Are held by the state in trust for the public and cannot be alienated to deprive the public of access
    3. Are owned equally by all citizens and cannot be regulated by the state
    4. Are international commons governed by treaties rather than domestic law
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Are held by the state in trust for the public and cannot be alienated to deprive the public of access

    The passage states: 'certain natural resources...are held by the state in trust for the public and cannot be alienated or appropriated for private use in a manner that deprives the public of access to and enjoyment of these resources.'

  2. Q2. In M.C. Mehta v. Kamal Nath (1997), the Supreme Court ordered:

    1. Compensation to be paid to persons whose riverfront properties were damaged by flooding
    2. The state government to acquire the motel and convert it to a public facility
    3. The restoration of the riverbed to its natural course and demolition of constructions in the riverbed
    4. A permanent ban on commercial activity within 500 metres of all rivers
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The restoration of the riverbed to its natural course and demolition of constructions in the riverbed

    The passage states: 'The court ordered the restoration of the riverbed to its natural course and the demolition of constructions in the riverbed.'

  3. Q3. The public trust doctrine provides a constitutional basis for environmental litigation because:

    1. It allows the government to acquire private land for environmental conservation without compensation
    2. It allows citizens to approach courts when the state fails to protect resources held in public trust
    3. It exempts environmental regulators from the requirement of prior parliamentary approval
    4. It provides for criminal penalties against individuals who damage public trust resources
    Show answer

    Answer: B. It allows citizens to approach courts when the state fails to protect resources held in public trust

    The passage states: 'It provides a constitutional basis for environmental litigation, allowing citizens to approach courts when the state fails to protect resources held in public trust.'

  4. Q4. The passage states that the doctrine has been extended by Indian courts to cover:

    1. Only rivers and other water bodies
    2. Agricultural land owned by public sector enterprises
    3. Forests, wildlife habitats, and other ecologically sensitive areas
    4. Urban parks and municipal green spaces
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Forests, wildlife habitats, and other ecologically sensitive areas

    The passage states: 'The doctrine has since been extended by Indian courts to cover forests, wildlife habitats, and other ecologically sensitive areas.'

  5. Q5. The doctrine of public trust has its roots in:

    1. The Indian Constitution's chapter on Directive Principles of State Policy
    2. Roman law (the Justinian Code) and English common law
    3. The Stockholm Declaration on the Human Environment (1972)
    4. The Wildlife Protection Act, 1972
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Roman law (the Justinian Code) and English common law

    The passage states: 'The doctrine has ancient roots in Roman law (the Justinian Code) and was incorporated into English common law.'

Prepare with CLATcoach, free

A free account gives you a full mock, a past paper for every exam, the daily questions, twelve Legal GK headings and a report on where you stand.

Create a free account